Deer Trafficking Conviction Results in Record $1.6 Million Fine

Benjamin N. Chason has been ordered to pay $1.6 million in fines and restitution, the largest sum of money ordered of an individual to pay for a wildlife crime in the United States, following his guilty plea in U.S. District Court.

handcuffsChason, 61, of Climax, Ga., pleaded guilty and was sentenced in U.S. District Court for three charges related to violating the Lacey Act. Chason was involved in a multi-state effort to move deer in violation of the federal Lacey Act and other state laws.

Of the $1.6 million, $600,000 is to be paid into the Ohio Department of Natural Resources Wildlife Habitat Fund $200,000 to the Federal Endangered Species and Wildlife Diversity Fund, $400,000 to Columbus and Franklin County Metro Parks and $100,000 to the Ohio DNR Division of Wildlife Turn
in a Poacher (TIP) program.

Carter Stewart, U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of Ohio, Gregory Jackson, Special Agent in Charge, United States Fish and Wildlife Service Office of Law Enforcement, Chief Scott Zody, Ohio Department of Natural Resources Division of Wildlife, Franklin County Prosecutor Ron O’Brien, the
Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission and Georgia Department of Natural Resources announced the sentence, which was unsealed yesterday.

According to court documents, Chason and co-conspirator Donald W. Wainwright Sr., trafficked in live white-tailed deer. Wainwright Sr.owned hunting preserves in Logan County, Ohio, and Live Oak, Fla.; both preserves were named Valley View Whitetails. Donald Wainwright Jr. was
part-time resident and part-time operator of the site in Ohio. Chason was part-owner of Valley View Whitetails in Ohio and also owned an extensive high-fenced property containing white-tailed deer in Climax, Georgia.

Wainwright Sr. illegally shipped deer to Florida from Ohio and attemptedto ship deer to Georgia from Ohio. The deer herds involved with these shipments were not certified to be free from chronic wasting disease, tuberculosis and brucellosis. Federal law requires interstate shipments of deer to be certified to be disease-free; because the deer in the present case were not certified as disease-free, deer herds (both captive and wild) in Florida were potentially exposed to these diseases. Tuberculosis and brucellosis can also be transmitted from deer to cows and humans.

The attempted shipment to Georgia was intercepted on I-71 South, about 50 miles from the Ohio River, when Ohio Division of Wildlife officers noticed deer noses and antlers inside a cargo trailer and pulled over a truck driven by Wainwright Sr.’s employees.

Wainwright Sr. and Chason placed federal identification tags from a certified deer that had previously died into the ear of an uncertified deer they were selling. They then sold breeding services and semen from the deer to breeders around the United States.

The defendants also sold illegal white-tailed deer hunts at Valley View Whitetails of Ohio. They induced clients from around the country to hunt at Valley View Whitetails of Ohio – charging customers from $1,000 to $50,000 to kill deer inside his high fence preserve when Wainwright did not have a hunting preserve license. The customers then took the bucks back to their
home states, including: Florida, Michigan, Alabama and Virginia.


“Illegal sale and transport of white-tailed deer are serious crimes and I appreciate the teamwork and cooperation between all of the agencies involved to help obtain these convictions,” ODNR Division of Wildlife Chief Scott Zody said.

“We are pleased to see the positive results in this investigation. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Office of Law Enforcement considers the potential spread of disease caused by the illegal commercialization of fish and wildlife resources a high priority, and we will continue to work
closely with our State partners to assist them in these important investigations,” said Edward Grace, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Deputy Assistant Director for Law Enforcement.

Chason pleaded guilty on May 1, 2014. Besides being ordered to pay
restitution, Chason was sentenced to three years of probation and four
months of home confinement. Chason also agreed to publish a statement in
North American Whitetail Magazine and perform 150 hours community service
in an Ohio or Georgia State Park.

Wainwright, Sr. pleaded guilty on February 27, 2015, to 12 charges related
to violating the Lacey Act, one count of conspiracy and one count of wire
fraud. He was sentenced to 21 months in prison, a $125,000 fine 200 hours
of community service to be served in a parks system and ordered to publish
an article in The Deer Breeders Gazette.

Wainwright, Jr. pleaded guilty on February 17, 2015, to eight charges
related to offering illegal hunts in violation the Lacey Act and was
sentenced to four months of house arrest and three years of probation.

Under the Lacey Act, it is unlawful to import, export, transport, sell or
purchase wildlife, fish or plants that were taken, possessed, transported
or sold in violation of a state, federal or foreign law. When it was passed
in 1900, the Lacey Act became the first federal law protecting wildlife.

U.S. Attorney Stewart commended the cooperative investigation by law
enforcement, as well as Special Assistant United States Attorney Heather
Robinson with the Franklin County Prosecutor’s Office and Assistant United
States Attorneys J. Michael Marous and Peter Glenn-Applegate, who
represented the United States in this case.