ORIGINAL: rem700
i've use wd40 four years, but i clean it out after.
Yeah, me too. I think the big problem is when you spray it in something like the trigger group and then leave it. However, I got to thinking twice about WD40 after a few threads on other forums. It's the kind of product that keeps gunsmiths in business. As a guy who does the occasional piece of 'smithing work for myself and others, I can tell you one of the things you frequently see is overuse of stuff that leads to build-up and lacquering-- nothing a little brake cleaner won't fix, but it can lead to the hammer not falling or a semi's action not working. I can't count the number of times I've helped out a guy with a firearm that won't fire and found a yellow goo gumming up the works. I've also heard that WD40 is not nice to bluing-- nothing major, but over time it'll make a black finish go grey.
My ace #1 suggestion: Google "Ed's Red" . It's Kerosene, Automatic Transmission Fluid, Acetone, and Mineral Spirits in equal parts. If you take the Kero and ATF and mix it 50/50 you have gun oil. If you put in the other ingredients you've got powder solvent that will also dissolve plastic buildup from sabots, shotgun wads, etc. Fr. Frog has the best page for Ed's Red formulations. My guns have had nothing but for about 7 years. It has an amazing deep-clean property. I do a once-over on the barrels at the end of season and then come back 2 weeks later. The Ed's Red has been working and all sorts of gunk comes out. Then I lubricate and put them away for the Winter. When I pull them out of storage, I run a dry boresnake down the barrel and get all the crud that's been getting loosening up in the intervening months. I mix and use Ed's Red by the quart. I also will take a little Ed's on a patch and (as and example) add a little acetone to go after a nasty smear of plastic I see in a shot gun barrel. Hoppes #9 would have me scrubbing for a half hour. If you have a favorite rust preventative, you can mix that into the oil formulation. Ed won't care.
I was wondering: why ATF? It turns out ATF came about as a synthetic replacement for sperm oil. They started making automatic transmissions just about the time all the sperm whales were disappearing. You gotta admit. You gotta admit ATF is amazing stuff-- you couldn't have an automatic transmission without it. It just so happens that sperm oil was the lubricant of choice for guns before whaling stopped-- it all makes sense.