by Osty » Sat Sep 12, 2009 7:47 pm
Putting in my 2 cents in.
I've hunted in North Carolina the past 6 years before moving. During October-December gun season, I hunt with a club using dogs to push the deer and limited to buckshot only. Some of the hunts the temps range from the 50-70's. We make 3-5 drives during the day spending about 1-2 hours in a spot. A deer (gutted out) that is shot sits in a truck bed during the whole day after being registered. At the end of the day we go back to the clubhouse and skin and cut up the deer into quarters or portions. "Killers" get the first choice, a hindquarter, until the lucky hunters are done. Non-killers get next choice. We rotate through like that until all the quarters of meat are gone. Well, I usually grind most into hamburger but have experimented cutting the deer up into "steaks" or "stew meat." I haven't seen any difference in taste even though the deer has been in less than ideal cooling conditions. I haven't gotten sick nor has my family from this.
I have packed ice into some of the cavities until the next day when I butcher/grind. I've also loaded quarters of deer into large coolers and packed those with ice. Maybe because I grind the meat, don't let it sit without ice, or let it sit any longer during above freezing temps might stop any spoiling or sour tasting meat. The parts with buckshot might be a different story.
During my early years in Wisconsin, and still today, any deer that I don't take to the butcher right away or the temperture isn't at least well below freezing, I usually put ice in the cavity anyway.
My advice is if you can't get to butchering right away, in warm weather, at least put the deer on ice.