Fullrut- In my opinion he's a very nice looking buck but he has the potential to be huge next year or the year after! Since you've already passed him up once I'd say keep with that mindset. One other thing I'd like to mention though is that it might be hard for him to live through another deer season if you are in an area where neighbors/surrounding hunters shoot any deer they see (just mentioning this because that's is kind of the situation I have around my area and it makes it that much harder to get big bucks). No matter what you choose to do, good luck! That's a great looking buck! I love the character he has!
Addicted to hunting!!