Which one would you take

[blchandler1981@yahoo.com]

Which one would you take if they where standing side by side broadside while in your stand?

This is the same eight I was getting pics of in early june. #1

dd1.JPG (95.55 KiB) Viewed 1235 times

This is the other buck that joined the bachelor group earlier this month. #2

dd2.JPG (95.2 KiB) Viewed 1235 times

I'm pretty sure this is #2 last year with the same buck he is with in this years pic. Passed him up twice last year.

dd3.JPG (93.76 KiB) Viewed 1235 times

[bmstaaf]

I would shoot the one who shows up with enough light.

[Jslotter]

Which one would you shoot? Our opinion shouldn't matter.

[ekka009]

I choose one that is more clearer to see. Light is matter for me.

[Rutnut]

The first one to present a kill shot for my bow gets it. If they both happen to do that at the same time, than #2 is hanging in my garage!

[msbadger]

The one that is not any where near that timed feeder....and gives me a good shot angle

[JPH]

I too am creeped out by the feeder. If that were a factor in the hunt, I'd go somepalce else.

If the feeder was not used, I guess I'd prefer to shoot #1 as he appears to be older. I would not pass an ethical shot on either one though.

[ishman]

id shoot # 1 and then the coyote!

[1ojolsen]

I prefer wild deer.