Welcome to the Whitetail Jungle

NoteDeer & Deer Hunting Editor Dan Schmidt has just returned from a weeklong hunt near Prince Albert, Saskatchewan.  This is the second installment of a five-part blog series on his adventure. Check back each day this week for updates.

Don't adjust set. This is all you can see when waiting for deer to appear in Saskatchewan.

Over the past two decades, I’ve been chasing trophy whitetails across 18 states and now four Canadian provinces. Some of these big buck hunts have found me pursuing whitetails in the far-reaching forests of Maine, Montana, Wisconsin, Ontario, Alberta and even Quebec’s enchanted Anticosti Island. Without question, last week’s trip to Prince Albert, Saskatchewan ranks at the top of the list for "most wild." Never in my life have I hunted whitetails on such a virgin landscape.

Day 1 of the hunt started uncerimoniously, as I chose to stay back at camp and make sure my CVA Accura’s Konus scope was still "on," while 80 percent of the other hunters headed on their 2-hour excursions toward their stands. We were staying at Garden River Outfitters just outside of the Prince Albert National Forest. This is ground owned by the Canadian government ("Crown" land) that is leased to outfitter Mo Heisler. He has been guiding big-buck fanatics up here since the 1980s. His reputation is unmatched, as is evidenced by photo after photo of smiling hunters kneeling beside B&C-class bucks. 

Heisler’s approach is simple. A born trapper, he uses his keen woods knowledge to pinpoint prime deer areas across his 200,000-acre range. Canadians call it "the bush." I call it one endless sea of forest.

"How far does this woods go?" I asked innocently while sitting down at the shooting range to shoot my muzleloader. "I don’t know," Heisler said. "Never really thought about that. Probably all the way to the North Pole," he added I think half-jokingly.

Nestling my cheek into the gunstock, I held a steady grip while centering the cross-hair on the target. KABOOM! Smoke belched out of the fluted Bergara barrel and hung in the 18-degree morning air. My eyes strained to view the paper target through the scope.

"Was there a mark in that bull’s-eye beforehand?" I asked.

"Nope," said Heisler. "Someone will meet you up by the camp house. You’re ready to hunt."

I soon loaded all of my gear into a warm, waiting truck and was headed north with Cal, Mo’s head guide and right-hand man. We drove on snow-packed road that I assumed were paved underneath. And drove. And drove. More than an hour later, we pulled off the road and onto a path that wound through vast expanses of fallow ground. Thirty minutes after that, we approached an endless wall of woodlands.

From there, we loaded my backpack, Heater Body Suit and cased gun onto a waiting ATV.

"Put your facemask on," Cal said. "This ride can get a little cold."

He wasn’t kidding. Seated behind my guide on a one-man Honda Foreman ATV, I held on to the back cargo rack like a bronco rider as we drove countless miles into the gut of a incredibly gorgeous old-growth forest. I’m a tree man by hobby, but I couldn’t quite pinpoint the species I was seeing whiz by us as we drove. However, Cal later told me these woods are populated by mostly white spruce and black poplar. Forty minutes later, the ATV came to an abrupt stop.

"Here we are," Cal whispered while pointing to an Ameristep Outhouse one-man blind buried behind some well-placed spruce bows. "I’ll refresh the bait on the way out. Good luck. See you at dark."

After unloading all of my gear inside the blind and climbing into my Heater Body Suit, I ripped open six extra-large air-activated hand-warmers and stuck them in my pac boots, pant pockets and chest pockets. I then zipped up the blind’s windows, leaving one open just enough to see down the 15-foot wide path to the bait station. That’s all I could see. This woods was so thick that a deer could have walked within 30 yards of the blind in any other direction, and I wouldn’t have seen it.

Although it did seem a bit odd that I had traveled all of these miles to sit in a woods watching a bait pile, I knew full well that this is really the only way to hunt deer in this type of environment and expect to see something. The week’s temperatures called for single-digits. Tracking or still-hunting these whitetails is an admirable fantasy, it would be downright dangerous. Heisler warned us the previous night to not even think about blood-trailing a deer in these woods.

"It’s very easy to get lost out here," Heisler said. "Oh, we’ll find you. But I can’t guarantee that we’ll find you alive."

With those pleasant thoughts dancing in my head, I was more than happy to cast my gaze toward the alfalfa haybale resting in the snow 89 yards in front of my blind in this North Woods jungle.

Deer & Deer Hunting Editor Dan Schmidt begins his vigil in the Saskatchewan wilderness.

Click here to read part 3: "That Has Got to Be the BIGGEST Buck I’ve Ever Seen!"

Earlier posts from this series:
Part 1: Big Bucks North of the Border

Big Bucks North of the Border

Note: Deer & Deer Hunting Editor Dan Schmidt has just returned from a weeklong hunt near Prince Albert, Saskatchewan.  This is the first installment of a five-part blog series on his adventure. Check back each day this week for updates.

D&DH Editor Dan Schmidt found he would have to endure many lines and complete lots of paperwork on his travels to Saskatchewan.

I don’t know who originally penned the phrase "Go Big or Go Home," but it was certainly a diehard buck hunter. Translation: If you’re going to travel 1,144 miles to hunt whitetails, you best hone your mental edge before stepping foot on that plane.

I’ve spent the past eight months doing just that. If you know me — and know me well — you know that I love releasing the bowstring and squeezing the trigger. I just love deer hunting (and venison) that much. But when CVA’s Chad Schearer invited me to leave Wisconsin last week and hunt the wilds of Saskatchewan with him, I knew that this was a "big or nothing" proposition. I also knew that — despite the fact that we’d be hunting deep-woods bucks over bait — this would be anything but a slam dunk. 

It certainly wasn’t. And I learned that months before the trip happened. This was my first trip out of the country since the early 2000s. Yeah, a lot has changed since then.

Although I traveled just last week, the paperwork began four months ago when I had to apply for my first U.S. Passport. In August, I spent a good part of two days shuttling between work, our county courthouse, my safety deposit box (to retrieve my birth certificate) and the U.S. Post Office. I was lucky I started the process months in advance, because the passport showed up at my home just a few weeks ago.

From there, it was more paperwork. From copies of my firearms declarations (for entry into Canada) to the names, phone numbers and addresses of everyone I would come in contact with while visiting (every form printed off in triplicate) … I stepped into the airport feeling more like an income tax auditor than a wide-eyed deer hunter.

It’s a good thing I had all of that paperwork with me, because the lines and additional paperwork at the Canadian customs took nearly as long as my connecting flight from Minneapolis to Saskatoon. But all’s well that ends well, right? I began my journey to the airport at 4 a.m. last Saturday. By 7 p.m., I was standing in Mo Heisler’s Garden River Outfitters camp with eight other diehard whitetail hunters admiring some of those massive, dark-chocolate-colored  racks that has made Saskatchewan famous.

A hunter from New Jersey admires a 195-inch buck taken at Garden River Outfitters.

Click here to read part 2: "Welcome to the Whitetail Jungle."

Bowhunter Bags His Biggest Deer Ever

Jason Pickerill with his biggest buck ever.

On Monday, Nov. 14 Jason Pickerill harvested a buck of a lifetime in Hancock County, Illinois. After sitting all day Saturday and Sunday to no avail, Jason spotted this bruiser around 9:40 Monday morning. The buck walked in slowly from around 45 yards as Jason placed his pin on its chest and patiently counted each yard of the buck¹s approach.

Finally, when the huge deer presented a slightly quartering away shot at 16 yards, Jason released an arrow from his Bear Anarchy bow and claimed the magnificent whitetail. Back at camp, Jason put a tape measure to the rack and learned that it grossed more than 175 inches on the Boone and Crockett scoring system, making him a true Illinois monster. 

From everyone here at Deer & Deer Hunting, congratulations, Jason!

The Best Sights of Deer Season

 This buck greets venison processing customers of Stone Ridge Meats in Wautoma, Wisconsin.

My favorite sights this time of year: blaze-orange clothing hanging from washlines; a pickup truck parked near a cornfield; and any of the "Welcome Deer Hunters" signs posted at convenience stores, truck stops, etc.

It’s good therapy. Doesn’t matter what kind of mood I’m in, a sight like this puts a calming effect on all of my daily stressors. It’s deer season! Embrace it. Enjoy it. Get out there and inhale it. It only comes once a year!

Here’s a challenge for all you "Whitetail Wisdom" blog readers: Send me your favorite photo of what screams "deer season" in your area. Can you top this butcher-store deer? Email your pics to me here at the office, and I’ll pick a few winners and award some prizes! Send the photos to:  dan.schmidt@fwmedia.com. We will post all of the photos online and announce the winners on this blog.

Bowhunting’s Worst Curse Word

Shoulder blade of a whitetail buck. Image copyright F+W Media.

SCAPULA!

Yep, it is the biggest curse word for any bowhunter. Want the best deer hunt to go bad in a heartbeat? Want the best broadheads to fail to do the job? Want the biggest buck you’ve ever seen to bound away never to be seen again?

Then hit this paddle of a bone squarely with your broadhead-tipped arrow. I’m not saying you will automatically lose your deer, but you won’t be in for an easy bloodtrail.

Yesterday, I helped a friend (and avid Deer & Deer Hunting reader) trail a buck he shot the previous evening. It was a big 10-pointer, he said, and it came past his stand on a straight line after hearing his faux grunts. My friend was about 18 feet up in a ladder stand, and the buck was about 25 yards away when he unleashed the arrow. The deer whirled and ran across a grassy field, heading toward a thick stand of red pines. 

Upon unleashing the shot, my friend knew his arrow hit high of its mark … resulting in the dreaded "Crack!" sound of the broadhead hitting the shoulder blade. He found his arrow about 250 yards from the scene; blood on the arrow indicated only about 3 inches of penetration. A dead deer? Most likely not. Although that much penetration would definitely puncture a lung on a straight hit to the chest cavity, it would mostly likely take 5 or 6 inches of penetration on a scapula hit. The problem here is the the arrow must first penetrate an inch or more of hide and hair  then break the thick, rigid scapula and penetrate beyond that bone and penetrate the chest cavity. Such hits will truly test your mettle … and your blood-trailing skills.

One more thing to keep in mind when hunting big bucks: The scapula moves in 15 degree angles (or more) as the buck walks. The above photo will help you visualize how that happens, and how the bone can cover the vitals at various angles. 

I’m curious to hear shoulder-blade hit stories from all of you, especially on deer that were recovered. Tell me about the blood trail (or lack thereof), and explain which tactics you used to find your deer. Just hit the REPLY button below to share your experiences.



The Deer Hunter and the Businessman

Shoulder blade of a whitetail buck. Image copyright F+W Media.

SCAPULA!

Yep, it is the biggest curse word for any bowhunter. Want the best deer hunt to go bad in a heartbeat? Want the best broadheads to fail to do the job? Want the biggest buck you’ve ever seen to bound away never to be seen again?

Then hit this paddle of a bone squarely with your broadhead-tipped arrow. I’m not saying you will automatically lose your deer, but you won’t be in for an easy bloodtrail.

Yesterday, I helped a friend (and avid Deer & Deer Hunting reader) trail a buck he shot the previous evening. It was a big 10-pointer, he said, and it came past his stand on a straight line after hearing his faux grunts. My friend was about 18 feet up in a ladder stand, and the buck was about 25 yards away when he unleashed the arrow. The deer whirled and ran across a grassy field, heading toward a thick stand of red pines. 

Upon unleashing the shot, my friend knew his arrow hit high of its mark … resulting in the dreaded "Crack!" sound of the broadhead hitting the shoulder blade. He found his arrow about 250 yards from the scene; blood on the arrow indicated only about 3 inches of penetration. A dead deer? Most likely not. Although that much penetration would definitely puncture a lung on a straight hit to the chest cavity, it would mostly likely take 5 or 6 inches of penetration on a scapula hit. The problem here is the the arrow must first penetrate an inch or more of hide and hair  then break the thick, rigid scapula and penetrate beyond that bone and penetrate the chest cavity. Such hits will truly test your mettle … and your blood-trailing skills.

One more thing to keep in mind when hunting big bucks: The scapula moves in 15 degree angles (or more) as the buck walks. The above photo will help you visualize how that happens, and how the bone can cover the vitals at various angles. 

I’m curious to hear shoulder-blade hit stories from all of you, especially on deer that were recovered. Tell me about the blood trail (or lack thereof), and explain which tactics you used to find your deer. Just hit the REPLY button below to share your experiences.



Best Broadheads Produce Best Bloodtrails

What are the best broadheads for bowhunting?

I readily admit that I had been a stubborn (not yet old) coot when it came to expandable broadheads. After dabbling with them in the late 1990s, I basically swore them off. "Not reliable enough," was my mantra.

I wasn’t the only one. Look at any of the popular press articles over the past 15 years or so, and a lot of other veteran bowhunters were on the same jag. That was until a few seasons ago when I shot broadheads like those from Rage Broadheads, New Archery Products and the TruFire Switchblade. I guess you would call these "third generation" (or is it fourth?) broadheads. These expandables feature blades that slide back — not cam backward — to open. Although I have had some of these types of broadheads basically blow up on me (bust apart on impact), I have yet to see one not leave a huge entry hole. If there is anything to be said about truth in advertising, these heads almost always live up to it in that regard on hits to a deer’s body cavity. In short, they create unbelievable entry and exit wounds and, best of all, almost immediate, idiot-proof bloodtrails.

I will always stop short of saying any single product is the be-all-end all of its class. However, as a whole, I will admit that today’s expandables have convinced me beyond a reasonable doubt that they are good choices for whitetail hunting. Here’s my take on the pros and cons:

Expandable Cons:
1. Not as durable as fixed-position heads.
2. As a whole, not as sharp as cut-on-contact heads.
3. Do not perform as others well when they encounter scapula bones and spinal columns.
4. They’re expensive (upward of $80 retail for three) and usually can’t be re-used.

Expandable Pros:
1. Very large entry and exit holes.
2. Almost immediate bloodtrails.
3. Improved cutting performance over first-generation broadheads (less energy transfer on impact).
4. Fly very close to field points no matter how well tuned your bow is.

The pros and cons are even, so what’s my final verdict? I will continue to use large, 2-blade expandables. Will I use them exclusively? No. There are many other bowhunting instances where I feel more comfortable using a strong fixed-position head. What’s more, if my age continues to limit how much draw weight I can pull (I’m pulling 64 pounds right now), I will most likely shoot cut-on-contact heads more often than not.

In case you’re wondering about the above photo, it is of the entry wound to a whitetail doe I shot last night. I almost couldn’t believe the performance. The deer was slightly quartering when I shot, and the two-blade Rage Titanium sliced a 3-plus inch hole behind the deer’s armpit. The broadhead made an equally large wound on the exit. The arrow was stuck firmly in the ground when I retrieved it. The deer ran about 40 yards before collapsing from massive lung and heart injuries. The bloodtrail was insane — not that I needed one to find the deer.

The end result: Instant venison. That’s how I like it.


How Close Did You Get on Buck’s Score?

What are the best broadheads for bowhunting?

I readily admit that I had been a stubborn (not yet old) coot when it came to expandable broadheads. After dabbling with them in the late 1990s, I basically swore them off. "Not reliable enough," was my mantra.

I wasn’t the only one. Look at any of the popular press articles over the past 15 years or so, and a lot of other veteran bowhunters were on the same jag. That was until a few seasons ago when I shot broadheads like those from Rage Broadheads, New Archery Products and the TruFire Switchblade. I guess you would call these "third generation" (or is it fourth?) broadheads. These expandables feature blades that slide back — not cam backward — to open. Although I have had some of these types of broadheads basically blow up on me (bust apart on impact), I have yet to see one not leave a huge entry hole. If there is anything to be said about truth in advertising, these heads almost always live up to it in that regard on hits to a deer’s body cavity. In short, they create unbelievable entry and exit wounds and, best of all, almost immediate, idiot-proof bloodtrails.

I will always stop short of saying any single product is the be-all-end all of its class. However, as a whole, I will admit that today’s expandables have convinced me beyond a reasonable doubt that they are good choices for whitetail hunting. Here’s my take on the pros and cons:

Expandable Cons:
1. Not as durable as fixed-position heads.
2. As a whole, not as sharp as cut-on-contact heads.
3. Do not perform as others well when they encounter scapula bones and spinal columns.
4. They’re expensive (upward of $80 retail for three) and usually can’t be re-used.

Expandable Pros:
1. Very large entry and exit holes.
2. Almost immediate bloodtrails.
3. Improved cutting performance over first-generation broadheads (less energy transfer on impact).
4. Fly very close to field points no matter how well tuned your bow is.

The pros and cons are even, so what’s my final verdict? I will continue to use large, 2-blade expandables. Will I use them exclusively? No. There are many other bowhunting instances where I feel more comfortable using a strong fixed-position head. What’s more, if my age continues to limit how much draw weight I can pull (I’m pulling 64 pounds right now), I will most likely shoot cut-on-contact heads more often than not.

In case you’re wondering about the above photo, it is of the entry wound to a whitetail doe I shot last night. I almost couldn’t believe the performance. The deer was slightly quartering when I shot, and the two-blade Rage Titanium sliced a 3-plus inch hole behind the deer’s armpit. The broadhead made an equally large wound on the exit. The arrow was stuck firmly in the ground when I retrieved it. The deer ran about 40 yards before collapsing from massive lung and heart injuries. The bloodtrail was insane — not that I needed one to find the deer.

The end result: Instant venison. That’s how I like it.


New Muzzleloaders Need Attention

It is wise to clean your new muzzleloader thoroughly before shooting it.

Your bags are packed, and the taxidermist is on hold. You’re ready to bag that buck of a lifetime while hunting with a brand-new muzzleloader. All that’s left is to sight in that whitetail gun and make sure it’s "on."

Right?

Wrong. Before taking that first shot, answer one question: Did you clean it first?

That’s right, that gun needs to be cleaned and seasoned before anything else.

I was reminded of this wise gun-care tip the other day while talking with friend Cory Johnson, who operates a small pro shop in central Wisconsin.

"A lot of guys automatically think they’re gun is ready to go because it’s new," he said. "But most of those new muzzleloaders oftentimes have residue in the barrels that needs to be removed for optimal performance."

The above photo is a prime example of what to expect. I took this photo after running several Quick Clean Patches through the new CVA Accura that I will be shooting in Canada next month. I’m only assuming the streaks on the cleaning patches are from residue from the milling process.

Another bit of advice is to "season" a new barrel after cleaning it for the first time. This is kind of like seasoning a new frying pan. In short, take some "bore butter" and spread it thinly on a dry patch. Run the patch down the barrel, then follow up with a clean, dry patch. This is supposed to provide a smooth, healing effect once the gun is fired.

I won’t be able to shoot the gun now for a few days (it’s been raining here since the weekend), but I will be more confident at the range knowing that I am starting from scratch with a clean gun.

Then it will be time to put this muzzleloader to the test on a big buck.


Guess the Score of this Monster Buck

Monster 10-point whitetail buck.

Here’s a fun exercise for today: Take a shot at field-judging this trophy buck.

Here’s what D&DH Editor Dan Schmidt had to say:

"I’m not saying that Brad and I are the end-all experts, but here’s what we guessed for a gross score on that big 10-pointer shown in the trail camera photo:

"My guess: 153 gross typical. Brad’s guess: 152 inches gross. We made these guesses without conferring with each other. My ‘guesstimates’ for the buck’s gross score:

"Brow tine: 4 inches
"G-2: 7 inches
"G-3: 9 inches
"G-4: 7 inches
"Main beam: 23 inches
"Mass: 17 inches (5+4+4+4)

"Subtotal = 66. Multiplied by two = 134   +   inside spread (19 inches)  = 153.

"How does that compare with your guesses? Do you agree or disagree? Let the debate begin!"